So you’re interested in the online dating world, huh? But you don’t want to just click on a few photos to see who is aesthetically pleasing. You’d rather join a website that is more serious about finding a match that suits you.
In a comparison of EliteSingles vs Match, the first option is highly dependent upon finding a match for you based on personality quirks (and answers), Match uses algorithms to find the best option for you.
If you’re looking for a dating site that operates like social media and lets you freely reach out to other users as you please, neither of these sites is that. Does that make them bad sites to use though? Not at all. It just means that you will have to whip out your credit card and pay for the service, but you should also feel more secure doing so.
Instead of just crossing your fingers and hoping the personality and photo match the person you meet on the first (virtual) date, you’ll go into these sites feeling more confident that this really is the person you’ve been talking to. Find out what else both sites have to offer below.
Elite Singles vs Match
Key Features of Both Websites
If you truly believe that personality matters more than looks (or just as much), then you’ll be more than comfortable on EliteSingles. This online dating site makes you put your money where your mouth is because you cannot move through the site without completing the sign-in process.
And the sign-in process requires an extensive personality quiz beforehand. Once you complete it, all the faces are blurred out until you pay. So you can either choose to really see if you want to invest more in the personalities of the (wo)men you see, or you can pay as soon as you finish to see if the faces match the answers that are given.
Match.com also challenges you to look at something other than how attractive users are. Without payment, you also won’t be able to see the people who may align with your Reversal Search and Mutual Search.
They can see you (if they paid), but you cannot see them. You have the option of messaging one person before you’re blocked. After that, prepare to pay to keep the conversation going. When it’s safe to travel, and depending on where you want to go, Match allows users to start planning trips and activities together.
You never quite know someone until you live with them or travel, so agreeing to go on a trip like this may give you all the answers you need about a future with this potential significant other.
Comparison of the Sign-Up Process
Both sites are generally about the same level of security and difficulty to log into. They both verify that you are a real human being via email address and questions asked. Both ask for photographs. Although moderators vet both sites to confirm authenticity, profile verification, SSL encryption, and fraud detection systems, keep in mind that spammers have money, too.
Just because someone paid to be on a website and has a valid email address does not guarantee that you’re not looking at someone’s photographs or looking at a boat-load of lies as their personality answers.
This is where in-person, virtual and inbox conversations come in handy. As you speak with this person (and vice versa), the goal is to make sure their answers and profiles match up with what they’ve put down.
Try not to remind them of their answers; if it’s true, then the answers should align without you having to point out that they said something different in the personality test or profile.
According to Match’s site, since 1995, it has serviced 24 countries and territories and hosts websites in 15 different languages. This includes Yahoo! Personals in Australia and North America, along with many countries throughout Asia, Europe, North America, and South America.
EliteSingles is also an international dating platform, which operates with partners in more than 25 countries worldwide. Also, more than 90 percent of EliteSingles members are over the age of 30 and hold an above-average education.
Ease of Using Each Platform
Once you’ve passed the sign-up process and paid to see photographs, a lot of the site will seem like any other. You still have the option to choose people based on aesthetic appeal, block users you’re not interested in, read messages, block users, sort out favorites, and more.
What Elite Singles does is help you ask the kind of questions that would be awkward on a first date; they just ask it from behind a screen so all users can see what the answers are. Match doesn’t answer those tough questions, but it also doesn’t allow strange users with no photographs to bumrush you with salacious messages just at the sight of you.
Are there online dating sites that are easier to navigate? Of course. But if they’re too easy to navigate and offer no blockage to keep spammers away, you may as well try your luck on social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Twitter.
The whole goal here is to find users who you know are looking for someone special and are serious (financially speaking) enough to pay to “play.”
And ideally, especially on these two sites, they’re looking more for relationships than they are friendships and/or hookups. (Make sure you check the profile to see if you two are in alignment with this. There’s no point in wasting time on someone who just wants “friends” while you’re trying to walk down the aisle.)
Pricing of Each
Standard plans for Match account holders start at $19.99 per month for a year (total of $239.88), $21.99 per month for six months (total of $131.94), and $33.99 for three months (total of $101.97). Premium plans (one profile review per year, message read alerts, monthly boosts) are a little higher at $20.99 per month for a year (total of $251.88), $22.99 per month for six months (total of $137.94), and $38.99 for three months (total of $116.97).
EliteSingles charges a little less. Pay $11.95 to $22.95 per month to see the photos behind the personality rundowns.
Pros and Cons
Although both sites require you to pay to see the person behind the name (or personality test), one of the main factors that puts EliteSingles on a higher bar is users know what the person they’re talking to would say in certain situations. They can read all about their work attitudes and how they argue; with Match, users still have to have the same kind of conversations that they would have on any other site.
Pretty much all sites (specifically those who charge a nominal fee) claim to have algorithms that match you up with someone that they think you’ll like.
But if you’ve ever been in the online dating world before, it’s not even mildly uncommon for the site to match you with someone you would’ve never physically dated nor pined for personality-wise. So this is a good test for you.
You can either approach these websites like blind dates and skip past what you “think” you want to find out what you really need—and maybe that’s that the algorithms know something you don’t—or you can focus on how to find the most satisfying partners for yourself and just use the algorithms as a helper instead of a surefire guide.
Either way, be prepared to have some email alerts that’ll leave you scratching your head while others will make you leap to the screen.
There are some highs and lows of both websites. Anytime you’re on a date and trying to think of something to talk about, without getting too deep too fast, you risk being considered too intense. With a site like Elite Singles, users are required to be “too intense” from the very beginning.
If they’re looking for something else, they need not even bother with this site. So chances are you’ll be wasting less time if you’re serious about being in a long-term relationship or marriage. With Match, it’s a toss-up.
Because there are no hard questions that are asked, you’re paying to see photographs of people that you’d like to believe are looking for more. (Some free online dating sites will allow users who mutually like each other to send messages freely. While Match offers this option one time, that’s clearly not enough to start a whole collection of conversations going.)
So which online dating site is the right one for you? It’s pretty difficult to tell. You know what level of intensity your dating life is headed in.
If you’re ready to get past the fluff and go straight into topics like education, careers, future-year goals, and relationships, Elite Singles is probably best. But if you just want to dip your toe into the dating scene, maybe try Match first, and then you can control how deep you want to dive into more extensive conversations.
Visit the Perfect DM homepage for more expert reviews.